An artists journey

Blog

  • Do I Have Vision?

    Do I Have Vision?

    We are artists. We all long to have a unique and interesting vision for our work. But many of us are unsure if we have a vision. How do we know if we have vision?

    What is “vision”?

    I think we tend to get carried away with very broad and heavy meanings of “vision”. Perhaps we feel we must have a divine vision from God. Or we might envision our vision requires the creation of an entirely new art movement.

    We need to give ourselves more leeway. If we go out to photograph carrying the burden of needing to fulfill a definition like these, we will be overcome with frustration and failure.

    Vision is hard to define precisely. One definition is: “Artistic vision refers to an artist’s unique perspective and interpretation of the world, shaping their creative expression and guiding their work.”

    That is probably precise, but not as helpful as I would like. Better is: “The distinct ability of an artist to perceive, interpret, and express ideas creatively through various artistic mediums.”

    I like that this definition mentions that it is distinct. Our vision is intensely personal. And I really like it being described as a process, where we perceive, interpret, and express. That captures the artistic flow very well.

    Rusty old Ford in garage©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Shaped by different forces

    We are all unique individuals. I don’t mean in the “special snowflake” sense. The reality is that we are shaped by different forces. Our background and experiences and interests and mental dynamic cause our brains to become wired differently. It is not just environment. I have twin sons. They were raised together and generally had similar experiences and opportunities, but they could not be more different in their personalities and capabilities and interests.

    How it happens, we don’t know. That it happens is what is important. And it happens to each of us.

    This uniqueness, this set of perceptions and abilities that set us apart is key to our vision. We perceive differently, we interpret differently, and we express our ideas differently.

    Tunnel through the mountains©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Photographers

    Have you been on a photo workshop or camera club outing where several photographers go to the same location and spend time shooting? When we have a review afterwards to show our work, you would think it would be just repetition of the same images over and over. After all, we were in the. same place at the same time.

    But that is not the result, is it? There is a wonderful variety in the images shown. Lots of comments like “I didn’t notice that” or “I didn’t see it like that.” Vision makes that happen.

    We notice that one photographer is drawn to the broad sweep of the scene. He uses mostly wide-angle lenses to capture the scope he perceives. The guy beside him, though, hardly notices the overall scene. He is in tight on flowers and details of the scene. A macro view. And the woman beside them may not care about either of those sets of subjects. She may instead be captured by colors and patterns. Maybe she even uses intentional camera motion to abstract the scene before her.

    The point is that each one was validly following their vision, and each one was producing different work.

    God beams in the mountains©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Opinion

    To me, the simplest concept of a vision is that we have an opinion and know how to express it.

    When we are a new photographer, we spend most of our energy figuring out how to work the camera. How to expose properly. What aperture should I use? How do I freeze or blur the motion in this scene?

    Then, when we start to get that under control, we start thinking more about composition. What “rules” do we follow to be correct? How can I make shots that score well in the camera club competition?

    For most of this time, we are following mentors we respect. Basically, we are imitating other people’s work while we figure out what we are.

    Eventually, if we persist, we come to the point where we say, “no, that is not me; this is how I see it.” Now we are coming into our vision. We are confident and experienced enough to have our own opinion and are getting close to being able to realize it.

    And when someone tells us it is wrong or scores us down in a competition, we are self-assured enough to say (maybe just to ourself) “No, I do not agree. My interpretation is different. I see what you are saying, but I choose not to act on it.”

    When we have a vision, it may be a lonely place. Our vision may be counter to the main flow. That is not only OK, it is good. Because at this point, we do not want to be making the same type of work everybody else is chasing.

    Foggy night in the park©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Why don’t I know if I have vision?

    I think for most of us, our vision is not something we are consciously aware of. Since it is based on our personality and feelings and experience and values, it is just us. It is the air around us. We breathe all the time but seldom think much about it.

    In the same way, we go out to shoot and produce some images that please us. We are not consciously aware of why they please us or our thought process to get there. They just come out of who we are.

    One way to examine your vision is a personal portfolio review. It is a good exercise to do occasionally, as a self-assessment. Go through your catalog and pick out the images you like best or that seem most important to you, not the ones that score best in competition. No more than around 20-40.

    Spend some time reviewing them. What do they have in common? Probably it is not the subject. It is likely your approach, your treatment of the subject, your point of view. This is your vision.

    Out the window - through a beer glass.©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Does it matter?

    Does our vision matter? Yes, and no.

    Yes, it matters, because it is the expression of where we currently are in our artistic journey. At this moment in time, it is where our education and experience and personality and maturity has brought us. It is not static. It will change as we change. But it is always our vision.

    But no, it does not matter in an academic sense. It is not required that we internalize and reflect on our vision to the point where we can express it verbally. Pseudo-scientific buzz words are unimportant. Current prevailing theories are just that, theories. They will change tomorrow as a new influencer comes to dominance.

    Our vision is our opinion about our art. Here, today, right now. It is completely valid because it is ours. No one can challenge it and say it is wrong. Our expression may be challenged as weak in certain areas. Perhaps we need more training in how to do what we are trying to do. But what we are trying to do is ours.

    Do you have a vision? Yes, if you perceive, interpret, and express your art creatively. If you have a considered opinion about your work, you have a vision.

    Your vision shapes and guides you. Be deliberate about it, but don’t worry if you have it or what it is or that it is not like other people. An artist must be tough enough to be willing to be in a group of 1.

  • Where the Road Leads

    Where the Road Leads

    I love to explore. Wandering and discovering is a great joy to me. I like to find out where the road leads.

    The road

    The title is Where the Road Leads. This is not accidental. Most of my exploration now is near to roads.

    Way back when I had a lot less miles on me, I enjoyed exploring “the wild.” Taking trails in the mountains or sometimes making trails where there were none was my preference (don’t tell the Forest Service or National Park Services). I longed to believe I had found places no one else had ever set foot on, photographing sights never seen. Sometimes, that was probably true;

    Now, most of my exploring is on roads. I do my photography out of the car, with few long hikes. Age does that to us. I’m not sorry. I enjoy my current explorations as much as I did climbing mountains.

    Winding path through forest©Ed Schlotzhauer

    No agenda

    A key to my enjoyment is carving out a block of time with no agenda. Being on someone else’s schedule kills my freedom.

    It is hard to get immersed in my photography when I know a clock is ticking away my time. I feel pressured to go too fast and “run and gun” my shooting. under time pressure, I often convince myself that this scene is not “good enough.” I must hurry on to find a better one. Sure, there are magic light times when great shots seem to be everywhere, and I am in a photographic frenzy. But that is dictated by the conditions, not by a clock.

    My wife and I enjoy taking river cruises in Europe. It is an activity that generally pleases both of us. But the time is structured. That is hard on me. I can sometimes step away from the group for a few minutes and shoot something interesting. But it is hit and miss.

    A compromise is that we sometimes go a week or more early to give me time to free explore some new area. That has been awesome for my spirit and for my photography. Even if I don’t get portfolio shots, it is refreshing and puts me in a better mood for the cruise.

    Freight cars, showy fields© Ed Schlotzhauer

    Open to discovery

    Just wandering is not the same as open to discovery. Some people wander when they are lost in thought or worried about something. This makes them inward focused and not open to discovery.

    Being open to discovery is an attitude. It is based on curiosity and rooted in hope. Hope is a forward-looking attitude where we believe good things are yet to come. The attitude of discovery tells us there are interesting things around if we are sufficiently open to find and recognize them;

    I have always had this attitude to some extent, but at one period in my life I got some good training. Once upon a time, we owned a timeshare. This was back when they were a pretty good deal. It was very good for us for several years. We had a premium week – prime ski season in Colorado – and we could trade it well. We always traded.

    But we discovered there was an unexpected side to the transaction. We traded for a week somewhere. They were nice places. Usually a golf resort way out in remote areas. After we saw the obvious sights, we were stuck with what to do with the rest of the week. I don’t play golf.

    We developed an active exploration ability. I don’t think there was any location where we didn’t fill up our time completely and were sad to leave after only a week. I typically would get the best map available and would try to find remote, out of the way sights. Or even just the roads less traveled. It was wonderful.

    The few years we did this was excellent training in learning to be open to discovery.

    Confusing sign post. Many ways.©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Stop and look

    But even looking and recognizing interesting scenes is only partially useful if we are zipping by them at 70 mph. Convince yourself it is OK to stop. Even to turn around and go back. This is a hard sell in our modern, fast paced world. There might be wails of protest in the car.

    Too bad. They won’t die. Interesting discoveries are worth spending some time.

    Go actually look at it. I’m not talking about jumping out of the car, shooting a selfie by something, and zooming off. Spend some time. React to it photographically. Let your creativity play.

    You may have come on some historical place you didn’t know about. Or an overlook opening a sight you had never seen. Maybe it is just a little out-of-the-way museum or gift shop or an art display in someone’s front yard.

    Stop. Spend some time. Enough to contemplate it a bit. It can take some time to let some discoveries sink in. You spent the time to discover it, give yourself some time to take it in.

    Giant flamingos, in Colorado.©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Paying attention

    As Peter Cripps eloquently put it recently, it is not necessarily about the photographs. The act of paying attention is more important. Creatively putting ourseves into the artistic process of finding a photographic subject, capturing it well, and editing and perfecting it feeds our artistic spirit.

    In some cases, we don’t even care about the final image. I have tens of thousands of images that I never look at and will never show anyone. But I feel they were useful to me to make them. And maybe to keep to remember an event or a place or where some road took me.

    Surreal art - in a front yard© Ed Schlotzhauer

    Where the road leads

    It is important to me to find out where the road leads. To follow it to places I have never discovered. But why?

    I believe this is an attitude and act of curiosity and creativity. I believe it helps to keep my mind active and growing. And in my photography, I greatly prefer interesting pictures of places no one had ever paid much attention to instead of overworked images of classic icons. It keeps me fresh. It is why I pick up my camera and go out to shoot.

    Slow down. Block out unstructured time to explore and shoot. Follow roads you have never traveled before. Stop when you see something interesting. This is art.

  • Instant Replay

    Instant Replay

    Editing is a pain. It is a big time sink. But I have begun to look at it in a more positive way. Often, editing is an instant replay of a significant event or image.

    Time

    People say digital photography is free. I dispute that. Although it does not cost a fixed amount per frame to shoot, each frame incurs a debt of time. When I come back from an outing with several hundred images, it takes a long time to go through them.

    I have said that I deliberately use a process of slow editing. It is an advantage to me overall, but it has costs. Let’s say I drive an hour somewhere to shoot, spend a couple of hours making images, and drive home. It might take me easily a couple of days or more to go through these images on the computer. And even after that, I often do not have what I consider the “final” edits of some of the images.

    So, it doesn’t cost me $1 a frame to shoot, so I am “free” to shoot as many as I want. But instead, the cost is many hours of editing time. Maybe I’m just slow.

    Broken tree branch© Ed Schlotzhauer

    Stuck at a computer

    And a complaint I often hear (including from myself) is that I’m stuck at my computer doing the edits when I would rather be out shooting. Well, yes, that is true. But the computer is where a significant part of our workflow happens now.

    Ansel Adams famously described that exposing a frame is only a start of the process. In his world, much time and effort went into developing the negatives and making the prints. Spending 8 hours making 1 print was not unheard of for him. Now days, that extra time and effort is generally spent on our computer rather than in a wet darkroom.

    As I mentioned, I find that culling, keywording, initially processing the keepers, grading, and sorting take far more time than exposing an image. That is without even doing the extra work to perfect a “final” image.

    Every time I press the shutter, I am incurring a debt. That debt will be paid in processing time at my computer. I understand this and accept it as part of the process.

    Whimsical antique steam locomotive© Ed Schlotzhauer

    Not creating

    Some people also object that editing on the computer is not a creative process. I can see where they are coming from. It seems much more satisfying to be out in the field shooting. I am starting to view it somewhat differently, though.

    I only shoot RAW images, so my pictures look flat and soft when they come into the computer. The process of guiding and forming the image into my vision for it has become interesting to me. I also recognize it as a significant part of the creativity of making a good picture.

    There is a reinforcing loop between my knowledge of the tools and the results I achieve with them. Learning more rewards me with more confidence and ability to creatively modify the images.

    So, I have taught myself to enjoy the computer work as not just a necessary evil, but a creative part of my photographic process. A huge photo shoot may overwhelm me and seem burdensome, but overall, editing is a necessary and creative part of being a photographer with our current technology.

    Rusty old Morris perched on a roof©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Disappointing

    I said that my photos do not look good when I first load them into the computer. This can be disappointing.

    Experience can help immensely. I know from experience that when I go out shooting, I can capture some good images, if my head is in it. Likewise, I know from experience that these ugly duckling images I first see on my screen can blossom into something much better.

    Some creative work in my image processing software makes them develop into something much closer to what I remember (or imagine) from the shoot. In most cases, the disappointment fades and the images start taking on a life of their own.

    Firetruck face© Ed Schlotzhauer

    Invokes memories

    But I called this “instant replay”. What did it mean? Going back over the images from a shoot brings me back into the event. I relive what I was feeling, what the weather felt like, the sights and sounds and smells I experienced there.

    Memory is very selective. Usually, we remember the good parts. Reviewing the overall shoot is a great reinforcement to my memory and a chance to relive it. Usually in a positive way.

    This is important to me, because as I progress through my editing process, the images tend to get sorted into different bins, independent of the trip or the event. For instance, a picture of a really great tree ceases to be so much “a picture of a great tree in northern Louisiana in the fall of 2026.” Instead, it ends up in a collection of good tree images. This is the way I ultimately will be using the image.

    The passes through the shoot before they are extensively culled and binned is my opportunity to reexamine the event and build memories of the group as a whole. I am not entirely callous about this, though. Occasionally a trip is meaningful enough for me to put together a collection of highlights to remember it. I have a few of these.

    Going back through one of these trip collections is a great way to jog my memory. It can be interesting to me to see not only the trip, but what was catching my. eye at the time, and it can be instructive to examine how I have changed and developed different tastes now, whenever “now” is.

    fence built of skis©Ed Schlotzhauer

    This is where it comes together

    I am not a big sentimentalist. I don’t spend much time looking back over past trips and thinking about the “good ‘ole days.” It amazes me, though, when I do look at a past trip, how my images cause the memories to flood back. It is like I am there again.

    Perhaps this is one reason I shoot so much. My images are a big part of my memories. It seems like seeing an image that is important to me will immediately bring me into context. I recall where it was, when it was, the circumstances around it, why I was drawn to it, what the weather was, and why I like it,

    This is not a trivial thing to me. It shows what a powerful force the images I have collected are in my life and why their ability to put me into instant replay mode is so important. The ones that survive my editing process, and often the ones that were hardest to edit, seem to have the most impact.

    Maybe there is a learning here. When I post an image in an article here or print it and hang it on a wall of a gallery, the viewers see it only in their own context. If the composition is good enough, or the color is vibrant or if it touches some emotion in them, then they may like it. But an image may be important to me for other intensely important reasons.

    It is difficult to say what makes a great image.

  • What Is a Photograph?

    What Is a Photograph?

    I still see people agonizing over how much processing they are “allowed” to do on their photographs. But what is a photograph and what does it become if it is processed heavily?

    Unique

    Photography is rather unique among 2-dimensional art forms. Other forms like painting construct an image directly on the media. It is immediate and tactile. With photography, we usually capture the image whole and then indirectly manipulate the pixels. The final image is produced later.

    The tools we have available now allow great freedom in the manipulation that can be done. So much so that some people cry foul and say, “too much, it’s not a photograph anymore.”

    Is there a rule here, or are people just expressing their preferences?

    abstract intentional camera movement view of a tree.©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Technology

    In photography, we never actually touch our pixels, and usually not the media. Light is captured by a sensor or on film. It is digitized. Then we process it as data in our computer. Even when we view the resulting image on a screen or as a print, we still only indirectly see the result of our processing. A pixel, as a digital value, is almost imaginary. It cannot be seen or felt or weighed.

    So, we must use a complex tool chain of technology to accomplish our results. Modern cameras are amazingly complex, with processing power that rivals computers of a few years ago. The digital files must be brought into our computer and processed with some of the available application software, depending on our preferences.

    Even to view the image requires complex technology. Web browsers or other viewing software using high resolution monitors. Printers with sophisticated error diffusion algorithms, using multiple inks to construct a pleasing representation of what we created. To make a print, the pixels are “sprayed” on a media by a machine, not by our hand.

    Even if you use film, it must be developed and printed. It is probably digitized. Then it goes into the technology chain I described above.

    Sunset at 40,000 ft©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Core of reality

    But despite the technology differences, a major factor is that traditional photography usually starts with a real scene. This, to me, is one of the great things about photography, but also a problem for many people. In normal practice, we do some corrections and tone changes, maybe remove some distractions. If we compare the result next to the original scene, nearly everyone would recognize that the photograph represents that scene.

    Because of the history of the medium and the nature of the photographic process, many people imply a contract that a photograph must represent reality. Reality being what was actually in front of the camera at the moment of exposure.

    If our artistic processing deviates too far from this implied contract, many people get offended. Or at least nervous and filled with doubt.

    The question seems to revolve around whether the artist claims the image represent reality or it is art. If I see a photograph of a news event, I expect it to be showing reality. Sure, the exposure could be corrected, and a few very minor distractions could be cloned out. But these changes must not alter the substance of what the image is showing. If a news outlet uses an image that is altered to significantly change the scene, or is created by AI, they will lose all credibility with me. I will never trust them again.

    But to me, art has completely different standards. I can’t help what viewers assume, but I can control my intent.

    Photographing a true icon - The Eiffel Tower©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Painting

    Let’s contrast this to painting. I believe the same standards exist, but to a lesser degree. If a painting claims to show reality, it must do so. Otherwise, it is art and it can do whatever it wants. But few people expect a painting to represent a scene in exact detail.

    Did you know that some portraits of Abraham Lincoln were somewhat false? He was a notoriously homely man. Some portraits softened his features to make him look better. That seems a gray area. Not a faithful representation but not entirely lying.

    At the other extreme are the paintings of Albert Bierstadt. He was a romantic artist of the 19th century who glorified the American west. I have been to some of the locations he painted, and I can attest that his images are complete fiction. But they were popular. In those days, very few people could visit those areas, so they believed his paintings as reality.

    But the nature of a painting is that the artist starts with a blank canvas and uses a brush or a knife or a pencil to lay pigment on the substrate. It is hands on and considered to be creative. There is little criticism if the artist takes liberties or completely makes up the scene.

    Even if you watch a painter working en plein air, the resulting image is seldom a faithful representation of the scene. They take whatever liberties they want to simplify, or eliminate distractions, or change it to be more interesting. It is recognized as being art.

    I have never seen one criticized for not looking exactly like the original. People hold photographs to different standards. Even other photographers.

    What is a photograph?

    So, then, what is a photograph and why do we treat them differently?

    I believe it is because many people have a model in their heads that paintings are creative works and can be anything the artist wants to do, but photographs are snapshots of reality and should stay that way. I believe this statement is too restrictive of photography as it exists today.

    In the 19th century, when photography became popular, the technology was crude. Photographers could only capture black & white images of still subjects. So the marketing pitch was that they can capture reality in an instant.

    We have come a long way. The technology has far fewer limitations. Very high speed or very long exposures can freeze or express movement. Dynamic range is extended. Digital prints are almost perfect. Editing tools are so good that there are few excuses for having an imperfect image – unless that is the artist’s intent. Parts of scenes can be composited together, or parts can be “painted”, or AI generated.

    Because of these greater freedoms, artists are now able to express themselves more. In the same way that Impressionist painters were completely rejected by their Realist contemporaries, we see photographers beginning to push the boundaries and make photographs into something different, and bring criticized for it. Something that does not follow the rules and conventions established by others is initially rejected.

    What is a photograph? Maybe it is anything you want it to be. Maybe the distinction is the contract with the viewer. Is it presented as reality or as art?

    Creative modification of a simple capture©Ed Schlotzhauer

    When is it not a photograph?

    I consider myself a photographer and an artist. In my work, I may alter the pixels any way I want to achieve the result I like, because I am presenting art to you, not documentary. I can blur or sharpen. Distractions can be removed. Skies can be replaced. I often composite bits and pieces of many disparate scenes to create something new. I have been known to stretch and twist and flip with little regard to the “truth”. of the actual scene. Sometimes, the more I can forget the original scene, the better my art gets.

    With all of this, I am comfortable calling my work photography. Occasionally I call it art based on photography. Depends on the audience.

    Since what I do is pixel based, and nearly all of it came from captures of real scenes, it is clear to me that it is photography. It does not matter much to me where the pixels came from as long as they are my original work. It doesn’t matter to me if the end image represents something that exists in reality.

    On the other hand, by my value system, if a digital image is AI generated or entirely drawn or painted, it blurs into what I would call Digital Art. The distinction being that there was no image capture at all.

    My position is that I will not use AI. I don’t like it, and I don’t plan to use it to create my images. I do not consider it photography. That’s my bias.

    My stance

    One of my granddaughters is studying animation. Most of her work is based on 3-D models. Is that photography? Not to me. And not to her. But if one of those artists chooses to call what they do photography, or if someone calls what I do Digital Art, I am not in a place of authority to prevent it. Labels are not important to me.

    So, a working definition for me is that it is a photograph if it was made mostly from photographic captures. The degree of processing makes little difference. If it was substantially generated by AI, it was not a photographic capture. But the reality is, there is no rule, and I don’t think there can be.

    My contract with the viewer is this: if I claim the image is truth, it should essentially represent the original – essentially, I am not a photojournalist. If it is art, then almost anything goes. Either way, I claim it is a photograph.

    I will not give you an AI generated image and claim it is a photograph I made. Neither will I go on a public rant against an artist who does. The philosophers and great minds can debate the fine points. I prefer to go on just making my art however I want to.

  • Behind a Mask

    Behind a Mask

    I’m referring to masks we use for editing digital photographs. They are one of the most powerful tools we have. A lot of magic goes on behind a mask.

    I will use Lightroom Classic and Photoshop for my examples, because I know them best, but this is not a how-to article.

    Adjustments

    Some of the most widely used editing operations in photography are adjustments. An adjustment means that some property of the image data is modified – more or less, color shift, higher or lower contrast, etc.

    I believe that all photo editing tools have some means of making adjustments. Some of them differ in the ability to make only global adjustments, affecting the whole image, or masked adjustments, affecting only a selected part.

    Whether global or selected, the adjustment alters some property of the image. For example, some of the Lightroom adjustments are temperature, tint, exposure, contrast, highlights, shadows, whites, blacks, texture, clarity, dehaze, vibrance, and saturation. There are others. This is just an overview.

    Aged old cottonwood tree in snowy fields©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Why adjust?

    I’m talking about adjustments as if they are a good thing. But why do we need them?

    When we load photographs into our computer, they are mostly in the form of a jpg or a raw file. A jpg file (broken acronym for Joint Photographic Experts Group – the jpeg was shortened to jpg back in the days when Windows only supported 3-character file extensions) is fast and easy, highly compressed to save storage, and VERY highly processed. The algorithms have already made the decisions about how the image should look in terms of brightness, color balance, contrast, etc. Generally, they look good as soon as you see them. Average, but good. They may need some adjustments, but usually little.

    A raw file is just that, it contains almost the raw data off the camera sensor. Almost, because all cameras do some processing of the data. It might “fix” bad pixels or apply some “secret sauce” algorithms proprietary to the manufacturer to correct for sensor characteristics or to give the manufacturer’s “look”. Each manufacturer’s raw format is different.

    Raw processing software, such as Adobe Lightroom Classic, reads the proprietary raw format, does Bayer filter demosaicing, and gets the data converted to an array of pixel values. The image we see on screen at that point is rather bland. Contrast is low, colors are not vibrant, it is not ready to share.

    By the way, the Bayer filter is one of the secrets that is baked into our camera technology. It is elegantly simple, but a little deceitful. Check it out in this blog. You do not have to understand it to take great pictures, but understanding it gives you a little more mastery of the technology.

    I only shoot raw files, but why do that if it requires more work? When it comes to my images, I’m a control freak. I choose to do the adjustments myself according to my vision rather than letting an algorithm do it. And raw files have much more data and can be edited to a much larger degree than jpg.

    Line of empty wine bottles©Ed Schlotzhauer

    A mask

    I said that adjustments can be global or selective. Masks are commonly used to do selective adjustments. Being able to work precisely on areas that need adjustment gives us far more precision and control.

    Think of a mask like a stencil. It blocks some areas from being altered but lets the adjustment flow through to other areas. Because we are using digital technology, the mask can be “perfect”. That is, it can totally block the adjustment where we do not want it. Or if you prefer, the mask can be a fractional value, allowing us to only let a portion of the adjustment through. This allows great artistic control.

    The concept and application of masking was not created in digital. photography. It goes back to stencils, block printing, wood cuts, watercolor painting, integrated circuit production, etc. With our current technology, it just becomes far easier to use it.

    Lighting candles©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Power

    Global adjustments are a big hammer. They change everything. That is useful, but not adequate. What if there is a small portion of the frame where we want to viewer’s eye directed? A masked adjustment to select only that area does it. It is more and more common to want to selectively lighten or darken some areas, to change the color of a small area, or to change the color or contrast of just the sky or a portion of the sky.

    These are examples. It would be impossible to list all the applications of masked adjustments. I believe that masking is a critical skill for photographers doing digital processing of images. If you don’t or can’t do it, you will be at a disadvantage compared to other artists.

    If an image is going into my portfolio, or if I am going to print it, it is almost certain that there will be extensive masked adjustments made to it. Masking has become such an indispensable tool that I can’t not use it. Why would I choose to ignore one of the most powerful creative tools I have?

    Antique Coleman truck. HDR©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Benefits of AI

    From my viewpoint, the last few years of maturation for Lightroom Classic has revolved around more and easier to use masked adjustments and AI-aided mask creation. These are 2 very powerful trends. And yes, AI is in there.

    A few years ago, only a few adjustments had any rudimentary mask capability, on an individual basis. Now, it has flipped. The app has extensive masking, and we can apply most of the adjustments through them. A much better model.

    Besides the manually created masks, there are many excellent AI generated ones. Sky selection has been around for a while, and it is getting much better as algorithms improve. So is the Subject selection. There is detailed ability to mask people, from the whole person, their skin, or clothes, down to just the pupils of their eyes. And they are pretty decent masks.

    Have you tried the Landscape mask? It is relatively new. You can let it find and create separate masks for sky, snow, architecture, vegetation, water, natural ground, artificial ground, and mountains. It is a great tool for quickly separating blocks of an image for individual work. The masks are usually pretty good. But like all things AI, it works well most of the time but fails spectacularly at others. I often try it first to see if it can tease apart the areas I want to adjust separately.

    The Adobe “AI” ability to locate areas and mask them is improving steadily and bringing us much benefit. If the AI can do what we would have to do manually, and give even better results, I would be crazy not to use it. Using AI to generate a mask is not at all contrary to my vows to not use it to create my images.

    Need Photoshop?

    The steady improvement of Lightroom Classic brings up a question I often ask myself: do I still need Photoshop?

    Much of the time, the answer is “no”. Well over 90% of my final images never see Photoshop. Lightroom is getting very adequate for most image correction tasks.

    There is another class of edits, though. The strength, and a weakness, of Lightroom, is that it cannot create or destroy pixels. It is a strength, because all our edits are non-destructive. Anything can be undone with no damage. But some image manipulation I want to do involves major pixel damage.

    A simple case is compositing. Lightroom cannot bring all or parts of several images together as one image. Photoshop does this without breaking a sweat. It is happy to do anything we want to any or all the pixels in an image. Many of these edits are destructive, that is, they cannot be undone. But if that is what I want to do, that is the tool that will do it.

    And in Photoshop, the masking is even more powerful. Learning to use masking in Lightroom creates knowledge that carries over, in principle, to Photoshop.

    Example

    Here is a simple before and after example of Lightroom Classic adjustments. There is nothing special about the image. It is just one I shot last week in the Rocky Mountains. The first image is a raw image right out of my Nikon Z7-II. The second is after some quick adjustments, many using masks. No Photoshop was involved. Which one, if either, would you rather show people?

    Fall scene. Original RAW image.©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Fall scene. After some Lightroom adjustments.©Ed Schlotzhauer

    Put on your mask

    I hope I have convinced you that masking is one of the power features everyone needs to become confident with. Accept it. Learn it. Masks create magic. They are one of the simplest image editing tools to make your photographs stand out.

    I think you will find your images will look better and have more impact when you get familiar with digital masking.